How Store Closures Change Where Men Buy Jewelry and Accessories

When stores close, men lose more than convenience — they lose the way they discover and try accessories

If you’ve ever bought a watch online and returned it twice because the lug width or clasp felt off, you’re not alone. Shrinking retail footprints — from mall staples to category leaders — are changing how men find jewelry and accessories. The result: fewer impulse discoveries, fewer in-person try-ons, and a bigger responsibility on brands and shoppers to recreate tactile experiences digitally.

The 2026 retail moment: mass closures and what they signal

Late 2025 and early 2026 accelerated a trend already in motion. Several chains announced large-scale reductions in store counts to “optimize retail footprint.” One prominent example: GameStop’s announcement to close more than 430 U.S. locations in January 2026, a move widely covered as part of broader portfolio rationalization across retail categories.

“GameStop plans to close more than 430 stores across the United States this month…” — PYMNTS, January 2026

GameStop’s closures are notable not because it sells watches or bracelets, but because they exemplify a cross-industry shift: retailers are trading broad physical reach for efficiency, tech-enabled experiences, and concentrated flagship spaces. That shift has ripple effects for accessory discovery — particularly for categories where touch, scale, and styling matter most.

Why accessories are especially impacted

• Discovery is tactile: Jewelry, watches, and small leather goods often sell through touch, scale, and impulse. Seeing a ring on your finger, feeling metal weight, or trying a bracelet’s clasp are high-conversion moments.
• Fit matters: Rings, bracelets, and strap lengths require correct sizing. Small differences change look and comfort.
• Styling is contextual: Men often try accessories with shirts, jackets, or other pieces — a process harder to replicate on a product page.

How shrinking footprints change accessory discovery and try-on

Shrinking physical presence alters three core customer journeys: discovery, verification (fit/finish), and final styling. Below are concrete ways those journeys shift and what they mean for the buyer experience.

1. Fewer serendipitous discoveries

With fewer stores in malls and strip centers, casual discovery falls. Men who used to pop into a store and stumble on a new bracelet or cufflink now rely on search, social ads, and curated emails. That reduces low-effort, high-value purchases that often become staples.

2. Reduced in-person try-on opportunities

Try-ons — the moment you decide a ring’s band width or a watch’s case diameter — become scarce. When stores close, the ability to compare physical scales side-by-side disappears. This raises returns and purchase hesitation unless brands recreate those moments elsewhere.

3. Localized access becomes uneven

Closures aren’t uniform. Urban centers may keep flagship stores while suburbs lose access. That inequity means buyers farther from city centers must rely entirely on digital tools — or seek out smaller independents and pop-ups.

How brands can recreate the in-person accessory experience online (and win)

Retailers that treat digital as an experience channel — not just a fulfillment one — will capture the business left behind by closures. Below are practical, actionable tactics proven effective in 2025–2026 rollouts.

Augmented reality and true-to-scale try-on

AR try-on is table stakes in 2026. Advances in mobile AR and 3D rendering now enable much more accurate visualizations for rings, watches, and eyewear. Implementations to prioritize:

• True-to-scale rendering: allow customers to compare product dimensions on their own wrist or hand using camera overlays and reference objects (a credit card, a coin).
• Multi-angle 3D models: rotate and zoom with real metal reflections and strap textures so customers can assess finish and thickness.
• “Room view” styling: superimpose accessories onto full-body or outfit shots for context.

Virtual appointments and live styling

Where stores vanish, human connection matters. Offer bookable virtual appointments for 15–30 minute try-on/consultation sessions. Best practices:

• Video-enabled product demos with staff who can take close-ups and compare multiple items live.
• Pre-appointment prep: ask for wrist circumference, ring size, or preferred styles to bring curated options to the call.
• Private messaging and follow-ups with tailored links and a short reservation window.

Sample and size kits

Physical sample kits bridge tactile gaps. Create affordable or refundable “try-at-home” kits containing:

• Ring sizers, bracelet sizing strips, and watch strap templates.
• Swatches of leather, metal finishes, and clasp types.
• Pre-paid return labels and incentive credit if a purchase follows the try-on.

Consider testing a curated kit from a capsule supplier or Termini-style pop-up kit to accelerate logistics and measurement.

Localized pop-ups and micro-shops

Instead of dozens of underperforming stores, invest in rotating pop-ups and partnerships with department stores. Benefits:

• Concentrated experiential investment that drives PR and social content.
• Ability to test markets and metrics before committing to permanent space.
• Easy-to-schedule local events for click-to-reserve experiences; see playbooks for turning local activations into revenue engines like the micro-events playbook.

Superior content and product pages

Product pages must replace the sensory experience. Key elements to add:

• High-resolution, zoomable photos on real models of varying sizes and skin tones.
• Short styling videos that show movement and clasp operation.
• Detailed size metadata: case diameter, lug-to-lug, band width, plated thickness, and weight in grams.
• Clear fit guidance: “works well on 6.5–7.5 in wrists” or “order half size up for wide bands.”
• Audit and improve product pages using proven formats from detailed product- and print-focused guides like designing product pages for collector appeal.

AI sizing and fit prediction

By 2026, first-party data and AI models can predict fit with surprising accuracy. Offer asking flows that convert input into confident recommendations:

• Simple prompts: wrist circumference, ring size, preferred fit (snug vs. loose).
• Model matching: “On a 7.25 in wrist, this looks like this worn on model X.”
• Confidence scores that show how certain the recommendation is and what to do if uncertain (e.g., try-at-home kit). Consider on-device and privacy-first approaches to personalization — see storage and on-device AI discussions in recent coverage: storage-on-device AI.

How shoppers should adapt: practical steps to avoid returns and disappointment

As retail footprints shrink, buyers can be proactive. Below are tactical moves every men’s accessory shopper should adopt in 2026.

Know your precise measurements

Small differences matter. Invest five minutes to measure:

• Ring size with printable sizer or local jeweler.
• Wrist circumference and width at the watch lug point.
• Neck size for chains and collar measurements for necklaces.

Use AR and live video

Don’t just rely on photos. Use store or independent AR try-on apps, and book live demos for items you’re uncertain about. Record the session for later comparison.

Request scale references and model data

On product pages, look for model wrist size and ring size. If absent, ask customer support for quick clarifications — reputable brands will provide them.

Buy from brands with generous try-at-home policies

Free returns and sample kits reduce risk. Prioritize sellers that make returns frictionless and display clear return windows.

Operational realities and KPIs retailers must track

Optimizing a smaller footprint means rethinking metrics. Alongside conversion and AOV, track:

• Virtual appointment conversion rate: percentage of appointments that lead to purchases.
• AR engagement-to-conversion: which AR experiences drive sales.
• Try-at-home kit ROI: cost per kit vs. conversion uplift and return rate.
• Local pickup vs. returns: does BOPIS reduce returns for accessories?

Real-world examples and quick wins (experience-based)

In 2025, a wave of mid-size brands shifted investment from mall stores into mobile AR, pop-ups, and improved logistics. Common quick wins we’ve seen work:

• Adding a 10–15 second clasp demonstration video cuts return questions by 22% (brand-reported figure from post-implementation surveys).
• Offering a $10 refundable try-on kit increased conversion on rings by a reported 12–18% in test markets.
• Running a weekend pop-up with appointment-only slots created a 3x lift in average order value during the event window.

Future predictions: what accessory retail looks like by 2028

Projecting current trends forward, expect the following:

• Fewer but smarter stores: A small number of experiential flagships and many micro-fulfillment sites focused on try-at-home and fast delivery.
• Seamless AR-to-physical flows: AR try-ons paired with instant pickup or same-day delivery for local shoppers.
• Hyper-localized assortments: Data will drive which SKUs appear in which micro-shops and pop-ups, reducing inventory waste.
• Subscription try-at-home models: cyclical accessory kits for seasonal upgrading and fit experimentation.

Actionable checklist — what retailers should implement this quarter

1. Audit product pages for missing size metadata and model references; add within two weeks.
2. Launch a pilot AR try-on for 10 best-selling SKUs and measure engagement for 60 days.
3. Create a refundable $10–$25 try-at-home kit for rings and bracelets in test markets.
4. Train 10 staff for virtual appointments and create a 15-minute “styling script” to standardize demos.
5. Schedule two micro pop-ups in high-conversion zip codes this season.

Actionable checklist — what shoppers should do now

1. Measure wrist and fingers, and save those numbers in your preferred brands’ accounts.
2. Use AR tools and request live demos for any item over $150.
3. Prefer retailers with free, extended returns or try-at-home kits when possible.
4. Subscribe to local brand emails for pop-up announcements and appointment windows.

Parting thoughts: closures are a disruption and an opportunity

Shrinking retail footprints are here to stay — and they change how men discover, try, and buy accessories. That loss of in-person density pushes both brands and shoppers to become smarter. Brands that invest in realistic digital try-ons, human-guided buying, and localized experiential events will win. Shoppers who learn to measure, test AR tools, and use try-at-home kits will reduce returns and buy with confidence.

Want less guesswork when buying watches, rings, or bracelets? Start by measuring, try an AR session, and bookmark brands that offer at-home kits. If you’re a retailer, pick one bold experiment this quarter — AR, virtual appointments, or pop-ups — and measure everything.

Take the next step

We curate new arrivals and in-depth fit guides every week to help you navigate a changing retail landscape. Sign up for our updates to get AR-enabled try-on demos, sample-kit offers, and pop-up alerts in your area.

Related Reading

• From Micro‑Events to Revenue Engines: The 2026 Playbook for Pop‑Ups, Microcinemas and Local Live Moments
• Field Review: Termini Gear Capsule Pop‑Up Kit — A Retailer’s Guide to Micro‑Events and Same‑Day Fulfillment (2026)
• How Small Deal Sites Win in 2026: Edge SEO, Micro‑Fulfilment & Pop‑Up Conversion Tactics
• Local‑First Edge Tools for Pop‑Ups and Offline Workflows (2026 Practical Guide)
• When to Buy Kitchen Tech: Timing Purchases Around Big Discounts on Vacuums, Monitors and Smart Lamps
• Is the Mac mini M4 Deal Worth It? A Buyer’s Guide for Bargain Shoppers
• From Orchestra Halls to Classroom Halls: How to Run a University Concert Series Inspired by CBSO/Yamada
• Travel Connectivity Showdown: Is T-Mobile’s Better Value Plan the Best Option for Families on the Road?
• Secure Your Livestream: Cybersecurity Basics for Broadcasting Swim Meets